Showing posts with label mark strong. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mark strong. Show all posts

Wednesday, 28 October 2026

Sherlock Holmes review

 Number 684 on the top 1000 films of all time is Guy Ritchie's 2009 adaptation of the classic Sherlock Holmes story


Sherlock Holmes (Robert Downey Jr) is a maverick, crackpot detective. He and sidekick, the far more level headed Watson (Jude Law) battle to stop the necromancer Lord Blackwood (Mark Strong) from his murderous plans. Rachel McAdams stars as Holmes' former flame Irene Adler.

Guy Ritchie is best known for his crime caper films Lock, stock and two smoking Barrels and Snatch. The latter is one of my favourite films. It has all of Ritchie's signature flair from his witty script to fast-paced editing to memorable performances. Did that translate well to the world of Sherlock Holmes? I'm not so sure.

I get that Ritchie and producer Lionel Wigram wanted to do something new and forego the usual Sherlock Holmes' cliches but Ritchie's style didn't fit into late Victorian England at all. Granted I"m not at all familiar with Sherlock Holmes but he and his world have always struck me as embodying a level of Victorian sophistication and restraint which was lacking here. Too much slow-motion. 

Robert Downey Jr was also the wrong choice for the sophisticated Sherlock Holmes. It was a bit like he was playing a modern-day tv detective or showing us Tony Stark as a Victorian detective rather than Iron Man. It was a buffoonish performance. It didn't help he lacked any form of chemistry with Jude Law.

Mark Strong wasn't a particularly memorable villain either. It didn't help he spent much of the film hiding in the shadows. Lord Blackwood was no Noriarty either. As for Rachel McAdams as Irene Adler? I would agree with other critics who said she was underused.

I found myself very cold upon finishing Sherlock Holmes. Considering how much I've enjoyed Guy Ritchie's other films, it was a disappointment.

Wednesday, 15 May 2024

Sunshine review

 Number 997 on the top 1000 films of all time is Danny Boyle's 2007 science-fiction film 'Sunshine.'

The year is 2057. With the sun dying, the only hope for mankind is to send a team of astronauts and scientists to detonate a bomb in the core of the sun. The team consists of physicist Capa (Cillian Murphy,) Captain Kaneda (Hiroyuki Sanada) engineer Mace (Chris Evans) navigator Trey (Benedict Wong) biologist Corazon (Michelle Yeoh,) pilot Cassie (Rose Byrne,) Doctor Searle (Cliff Curtis) and comms/first officer Harvey (Troy Garrity.) Chipo Chung and Mark Strong also star.

There is a lot of good about this film, so let's get the bad stuff out the way first. Notably the accents. To reflect the international nature of space missions, Danny Boyle chose a deliberately international cast. Cillian Murphy is Irish, Hiroyuki Sanada is Japanese, Michelle Yeoh is Malayasian, Benedict Wong is Chinese, Cliff Curtis is Maori, Chipo Chung is Zimbabwean, Mark Strong is English, and Australia is also represented with Rose Byrne.

You have this internationally diverse cast, so why were Murphy, Byrne, Curtis and Chung all doing American accents. And why was Mark Strong doing a South African accent? One of the producers said it was to appeal more to an American audience, so why were Yeoh and Wong not included in this? Either have all the characters do American accents or none of them. It was a strange choice.

Pinbacker definitely could have used some more fleshing out as a villain. We quickly understand that he has lost his sanity, but little else beyond that. Sunrise was written by Alex Garland who had originally included strong themes of religion which were edited out. Elements of this remained in Pinbacker's character, but he remained largely undeveloped and two-dimensional.

Harvey's character was also the least developed among the crew. It wasn't really until the halfway point where Garland realised he had a scene with no conflict, and so he had Harvey commit a random villainous act that completely came out of nowhere.

But these criticisms aside, I thoroughly enjoyed Sunrise. Unlike sci-fi *cough cough* Space odyssey, it doesn't prioritise its big themes over its characters. The aforementioned characters aside, the remaining cast was well-characterised. These were complimented by some good performances. I thought Benedict Wong gave a standout performance. But this isn't to discredit the rest of the cast either.

For a big ensemble cast, I was surprised to find myself caring about most of the characters even if Garland didn't really know what to do with Cassie.

Visually, the film looked stunning. There were so many lens flares I thought I was watching a J.J Abrams film, but otherwise the CGI was gorgeous. I am, of course, excluding the final section, which looked like it had been shot and edited by a group of teenagers. Way too much shaky-cam and distortion. Also how did Cassie and Pinback end up on the same part of the ship that Capa needed to get to?

Yes, Sunshine is pure hokum, scientifically speaking, but the film's technical advisor Dr Brian Cox said that some inconsistencies are to be expected. This is a film and not a documentary after all.

Overall, I really enjoyed Sunshine. It's a great example of sci-fi done right.