Number 466 on the top 1000 films of all time is the Swedish thriller 'The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo."
Mikael Blomkyist (Michael Nyqvist) is a disgraced journalist who has just lost a high-profile libel case. He is enlisted by Henrik Vanger (Sven-Bertil Taube) the patriarch of the wealthy Vanger family - to solve the four decade disappearance, and suspected murder, of his niece Harriet. Mikael joins forces with the brilliant, but troubled hacker Lisbeth Salander (Noomi Rapace) to solve the mystery.
Two years ago, I watched the 2011 American remake of this film which starred Daniel Craig and Rooney Mara. It was ranked forty-three steps above the original. IMDB thought the remake was better - perhaps it was with Rooney Mara deservingly receiving a Best Actress Oscar nod. However, the 2011 remake could only run because the original walked first.
This film was gripping and enthralling with plenty of twists and turns. Nyquist and Rapace were every bit the quals of Craig and Mara. Best of all, the accents were more in line with what I would from a Swedish film; in the remake, the accents were all over the place. Not the case here.
One thing I didn't like about either film was the romantic subplot between Lisbeth and Mikael. In the remake, it was more romantic, but in the original, it was physical. In both films, Lisbeth is the initiator. However, Lisbeth was subject to a horrific rape from her legal guardian - of which she took an awesome but vicious revenge. But she then initiates sex with Mikael. And I thought this was unrealistic. Surely the last thing an SA survivor would want to do is to have sex with another man. It was unbelievable and contrived.
This isn't to disparage Rapace's performance of course. She earned numerous awards for a reason. Salander was a difficult character to play, but Rapace did her justice - like I said, she was every bit as convincing as Rooney Mara. Nyquist was also good as the journalist who upon stumbling upon an even bigger mystery, soon finds himself dangerously out of his depth.
Unconvincing and unnecessary love story aside, I thought the Girl with a Dragon Tattoo was a thrilling watch. Perhaps even better than its 2011 American remake.
No comments:
Post a Comment