Spoiler alert
Explicit content alert
So in reviewing Stephen Stainberg’s
2002 film ‘Secretary,’ I am reviewing something a little different. Secretary is an erotic thriller in much the
same vein as 50 Shades of Grey. I had
the misfortune of watching 50 Shades and I would agree with many reviewers who
say that not only is Secretary cinematically superior to 50 shades, but also a
more accurate depiction of BDSM. I was
initially hesitant about reviewing this film because of the risqué nature of
its content, but I felt that as a reviewer I need to stay objective and not be
concerned about the content matter of a film.
Furthermore, modern society has become so desensitised to sex, due to
the proliferation and over-saturation of it that I think that more should be done to educate people about lesser known
sexual practices, rather than feign ignorance of their existence. I guess this is perhaps the only good thing
that came out of 50 Shades of Grey. I
will be comparing the two throughout the review, but I’ll save any detailed
critique of 50 Shades for a proper review
What’s it about: Maggie
Gyllenhaal plays Lee Holloway a ditzy, nervous and socially awkward young woman
with a history of self-abuse. Upon her
release from a psychiatric institution, she becomes the secretary of the
attorney Edward Grey (James Spader) and the two then begin a BDSM style
relationship.
The Good: I liked
certain elements of Holloway’s and Grey’s characters. I felt that Holloway was suitably nervous and
insecure about the relationship, but also has the curiosity and initiative to
research BDSM. This in stark contrast to
Ana Steele whom despite being told by Christian to research BDSM doesn’t have
the initiative to google what a buttplug is.
Edward Grey wasn’t anywhere near as creepy, controlling, stalkerish,
unethical or rapey as Christian Grey.
I also really liked how Secretary focused much more on the romantic side of Edward and Lee’s relationship, rather than the physical side of it. I felt that 50 Shades concentrated so much about showing off explicit, kinky sex that it got a little off-putting at times. Secretary isn’t like that at all and the sexual content is much more subtle and implicit. The one time that complete sexual intercourse was portrayed was an awkward, comedic affair between Holloway and her sexually vanilla boyfriend Peter. I also really liked how Secretary had Holloway’s internal voice narrating it, which I felt 50 Shades lacked.
I also really liked how Secretary focused much more on the romantic side of Edward and Lee’s relationship, rather than the physical side of it. I felt that 50 Shades concentrated so much about showing off explicit, kinky sex that it got a little off-putting at times. Secretary isn’t like that at all and the sexual content is much more subtle and implicit. The one time that complete sexual intercourse was portrayed was an awkward, comedic affair between Holloway and her sexually vanilla boyfriend Peter. I also really liked how Secretary had Holloway’s internal voice narrating it, which I felt 50 Shades lacked.
The Bad: Whilst
there were parts of Holloways’ character that I liked, there were also some
that I didn’t. Most noticeably, I really
didn’t like her treatment of her boyfriend Peter. (Jeremy Davies) Whilst he
might be a spineless wimp, he certainly didn’t deserve being cheated or even
jilted, which is effectively what Lee does.
Whilst Grey does make an explicit point about not having sex with Lee
until she is ready, I would still count having your boss spank you or finishing
over you, as cheating, or at the very least, wildly inappropriate
behaviour. On this note, I think
Holloway could have been more hesitant or irritated at her employer’s
actions. Regardless of how shy and timid
you might be, you would still protest if your boss started spanking you.
Whilst I think the film did well in not being explicitly about BDSM sex, I’m not sure whether it went far enough in actually defining what BDSM is. In 50 Shades, there is considerable screentime devoted to the importance of Ana approving her contract and being fully informed of what BDSM actually is and what it entails. As Secretary didn’t mention these aspects at all, I wasn’t entirely sure when Holloway and Grey actually began their BDSM relationship. Although that notwithstanding, I did like the film’s conclusion, where Grey gives appropriate aftercare to Holloway, which Christian Grey doesn’t do to Ana Steele. Finally, after the climax of the film, which I would argue is the slow-motion montage of Holloway doing secretarial tasks in manacles and being spanked, the film’s pace begins to taper off. I argue that the climax of this film came too prematurely and the rest of the film was uninteresting, over-long and thin denouement.
Whilst I think the film did well in not being explicitly about BDSM sex, I’m not sure whether it went far enough in actually defining what BDSM is. In 50 Shades, there is considerable screentime devoted to the importance of Ana approving her contract and being fully informed of what BDSM actually is and what it entails. As Secretary didn’t mention these aspects at all, I wasn’t entirely sure when Holloway and Grey actually began their BDSM relationship. Although that notwithstanding, I did like the film’s conclusion, where Grey gives appropriate aftercare to Holloway, which Christian Grey doesn’t do to Ana Steele. Finally, after the climax of the film, which I would argue is the slow-motion montage of Holloway doing secretarial tasks in manacles and being spanked, the film’s pace begins to taper off. I argue that the climax of this film came too prematurely and the rest of the film was uninteresting, over-long and thin denouement.
The Ugly: Does
Lee Holloway only own the one pair of underwear?
Rating: Meh
So, I felt quite indifferent about
this film. Whilst it is lightyears
better than 50 Shades in every regard, it isn’t perfect. Holloway was an annoying, unlikeable character
at times and the film isn’t explicit enough in its BDSM themes. If you are going to watch a film of this
nature, then don’t be like Ana Steele, take the initiative and do a little
research first. A concept like BDSM much
like certain books like Ulysses is extensive and complicated and you’re
unlikely to fully understand it or be able to fully immerse yourself in it if
you don’t know what it’s about beforehand.
Hey, one comment, Lee technically never cheated on Peter, you misunderstand their relationship, he is her ex-boyfriend, but she hasn't taken him back when they start seeing each other again and have sex (she even tells him she is unsure of what she wants, and ask if they can just be friends). Then after Grey fires her she experiments a ton before she goes back to Peter, but realizes she is unhappy and leaves him and runs back to Gray.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I don't think Peter is suppose to be read as a nice guy, he is kind of creepy throughout the movie, and then after Lee jilts him he basically attacks her.
Delete